Offline
What's your opinions on them? Not that convinced with either of them tbh.
Offline
Get Alexander to play until the other keeper is fit.
Offline
Not convinced by either of them. Mehmet much better than either of them based on what I’ve seen so far.
Offline
JerryDungle wrote:
Not convinced by either of them. Mehmet much better than either of them based on what I’ve seen so far.
Agree re Mehmet. Blooming eejit injuring himself !!
The two big lads are fine, what's this shite about getting Alexander playing, that's cuckoo land.
Rakovan flogged one v Ross County with a howling wind in a packed 6-yard box & Siegrist has barely paid so give them a chance for fuck's sake.
And Deniz would have one game back before being resigned to the fans' scrapheap.
Supporters nowadays are the pits.
Take it you're all superstars at your work.
Offline
smedDUm, while I see your point regarding fans slagging players, it's a bit of a stretch to say Rakovan flogged one v County. He was the most culpable on the pitch for all five.
And social media is possibly as much to blame for players hearing more slagging than ever before, it always happened.
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
The two big lads are fine, what's this shite about getting Alexander playing, that's cuckoo land.
Rakovan flogged one v Ross County with a howling wind in a packed 6-yard box & Siegrist has barely paid so give them a chance for fuck's sake.
And Deniz would have one game back before being resigned to the fans' scrapheap.
Supporters nowadays are the pits.
Take it you're all superstars at your work.
We not allowed opinions smeds? In my opinion both our keepers thats been used this season arnt that good. Rakovan the slightly better.
I'm not booing them ffs, merely asking people's thoughts.
Offline
blackandtangerine wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
The two big lads are fine, what's this shite about getting Alexander playing, that's cuckoo land.
Rakovan flogged one v Ross County with a howling wind in a packed 6-yard box & Siegrist has barely paid so give them a chance for fuck's sake.
And Deniz would have one game back before being resigned to the fans' scrapheap.
Supporters nowadays are the pits.
Take it you're all superstars at your work.We not allowed opinions smeds? In my opinion both our keepers thats been used this season arnt that good. Rakovan the slightly better.
I'm not booing them ffs, merely asking people's thoughts.
No one’s allowed a subjective opinion around Smeddum. You either toe the party line or fuck off.
They're not world-beaters, don't profess to be, but it's all we've got so we better get on with it.
The whole team downed tools in the 1-5 game, not just the goalie, and he got dropped.
Siegrist has started in 2 League cup games & 2 Irn Bru games, I saw 3 of them (wasn't at Elgin 4-0) and he looked assured enough. Wasn't at Ayr either but he was ok by all accounts.
But the default position is 'he's shite' if you've never seen him. Mehmet should play. Well that's a joke cos he's shite as well. Or will be if he ever gets a game or two.
Goalies are all about confidence so why not try instil some in them from the terraces instead of heaping unfair criticism on them.
Back the goalies.
Offline
blackandtangerine wrote:
What's your opinions on them? Not that convinced with either of them tbh.
Not really a fan of either but for me Siegrist is better of the two.
If Luis Zwick or Srozmnik etc had put in a performance like Rakovan did v county they would have been given dogs abuse.
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
The two big lads are fine, what's this shite about getting Alexander playing, that's cuckoo land.
Rakovan flogged one v Ross County with a howling wind in a packed 6-yard box & Siegrist has barely paid so give them a chance for fuck's sake.
And Deniz would have one game back before being resigned to the fans' scrapheap.
Supporters nowadays are the pits.
Take it you're all superstars at your work.
This shite about getting Alexander to play is my humble opinion if that's all right by you. I think he's a much better keeper than either of the 2 we are currently using and he was a part of the successful Livi team that managed to get promoted last season.
As for shite posts on this forum, a good few seem to come from your direction. IMHO of course.
I hope Robbie Neilson doesn't pick Neil Alexander tomorrow.
Could cause a storm.
Your opinion, if you are serious, re playing a retired goalkeeper is most definitely humble.
IMC*O.
Considered
Offline
I don't know if he is still registered as a player. All I was saying was I think he's a better keeper.
Offline
let's get Hamish back
Offline
KdyArab wrote:
blackandtangerine wrote:
What's your opinions on them? Not that convinced with either of them tbh.
Not really a fan of either but for me Siegrist is better of the two.
If Luis Zwick or Srozmnik etc had put in a performance like Rakovan did v county they would have been given dogs abuse.
If Zwick or Srozmnik put in a performance like that, that would go down as good day for either of those two clowns. Our current 2 look pretty average but thats to be expected if you sign for a championship team
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
I hope Robbie Neilson doesn't pick Neil Alexander tomorrow.
Could cause a storm.
Your opinion, if you are serious, re playing a retired goalkeeper is most definitely humble.
IMC*O.
Considered
I remember in January you were defending the resigning of Mikkelsen and also berating people’s opinions on Emil Lyng
Was that a considered opinion as well?
Doesn't sound like me EHA. No way would I have defended the resigning of TM.
And EL - that would have been me berating fans for condemning him before he'd kicked a ball, a bit similar to Siegrist topically.
EL btw holds the Dundee United record for goals per game. 100%. 1 start, 1 goal.
FACT.
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
EL btw holds the Dundee United record for goals per game. 100%. 1 start, 1 goal.
FACT.
Not FACT.
Offline
Most fans my age (ish, mid 40's) saw some good times with good keepers a part of it. I kind of expect not to have a debatable keeper so I get where BLT is coming fae here. Does that sound spoiled?
Tek wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
EL btw holds the Dundee United record for goals per game. 100%. 1 start, 1 goal.
FACT.Not FACT.
Did he start 2 games?
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
Tek wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
EL btw holds the Dundee United record for goals per game. 100%. 1 start, 1 goal.
FACT.Not FACT.
Did he start 2 games?
He started 5 and came off the bench in another 5.
P.s. his goal at Alloa was a deflected fluke.
Tek wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
Tek wrote:
Not FACT.
Did he start 2 games?
He started 5 and came off the bench in another 5.
P.s. his goal at Alloa was a deflected fluke.
Apologies, 5 starts seems an awful lot.
He scored on debut then FACT and yes, it was deflected FACT
Offline
smedDUm wrote:
Tek wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
Did he start 2 games?
He started 5 and came off the bench in another 5.
P.s. his goal at Alloa was a deflected fluke.
Apologies, 5 starts seems an awful lot.
He scored on debut then FACT and yes, it was deflected FACT
It wasn't his debut Smedz.
Offline
Tek wrote:
smedDUm wrote:
Tek wrote:
He started 5 and came off the bench in another 5.
P.s. his goal at Alloa was a deflected fluke.
Apologies, 5 starts seems an awful lot.
He scored on debut then FACT and yes, it was deflected FACT
It wasn't his debut Smedz.
You've had a nightmare there smed FACT.