Tekel Towers » Zwick or Rado?

Tangy · 15/9/2015 1:38 pm

Who would you want in goal right now?

On one hand, Zwick has a lot of learning to do - on the other rado was partial to a 'clanger'

For me, rado edges it.... in a couple of years, I'm sure I'd say zwick

Sieb22 · 15/9/2015 2:06 pm

Zwick.

No goalkeeper is infallible, and feel a bit sorry for him as a lot of people get hung up about his young age and seems to be under the microscope more.

If he was Rado's age I don't think there would be that much fuss about making him our No.1.

BIGH4RRY · 15/9/2015 2:24 pm

Zwick for me, not a bad shot stopper but like you say definitely has some learning to do.

Rado was a total bombscare in his last season and was in serious decline before that.

Last edited by BIGH4RRY (15/9/2015 2:26 pm)

Luggy's Shins · 15/9/2015 2:29 pm

Zwick, bar the Dundee second goal has done fine, and I like that he comes for crosses with real commitment. Something Rado nor Pernis before him did. I liked Rado, but his goalkeeping was pretty inconsistent - and mentally he could be all over the shop. Sadly for him, all I can think of is the Cup Final.

SuperMario · 15/9/2015 3:23 pm

Zwick every day of the week, looks brilliant! Rado was a liability

Tangerine_Ultra · 15/9/2015 4:06 pm

Zwick by a million miles.

Morphman · 15/9/2015 5:11 pm

Zwick for me, I liked Rado but bar Dundee's equaliser in the derby he hasn't put a foot wrong IMO. Our usual defensive shambles leaving him out to dry every week. The Hamilton game could've been double figures if it weren't for Luis.

RRDH · 15/9/2015 5:41 pm

zwick

Strummer · 15/9/2015 7:53 pm

Zwick.

About the only good thing going on at Utd the now.

Jordan_thearab · 15/9/2015 8:21 pm

Cant belive this has even been posted if it wasnt for zwick we would be -50 goals by now lads better than rado and hes improving game by game

Tangy · 15/9/2015 10:29 pm

Calm Yersel doon, son.... just a query and tbh beats 40 threads entitled 'jackie out' or 'ST is a knob'

I'd say rado made more 'good' stops but was a bit of a bombscare at times.

Right now, In my opinion, Zwick is more steady but less likely to make those good saves. I think he's learning all the time though.

TheShed · 15/9/2015 10:34 pm

Zwick is no better or worse than Rado, but will potentially get better. Rado wouldn't.

Still not convinced Zwicks the best keeper at the club yet tho, think his performances are being played up a bit tbh.

Arab_plumber · 15/9/2015 11:38 pm

Zwick for me

Index
» Dundee United
» Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 1:38 pm #1

Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 2:06 pm #2

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 2:24 pm #3

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 2:29 pm #4

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 3:23 pm #5

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 4:06 pm #6

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 5:11 pm #7

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 5:41 pm #8

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 7:53 pm #9

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 8:21 pm #10

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 10:29 pm #11

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 10:34 pm #12

Re: Zwick or Rado?

15/9/2015 11:38 pm #13

Re: Zwick or Rado?

Index
» Dundee United
» Zwick or Rado?

Board footera