Why would you change it after our first decent performance in a long time?

We really do not need three sitting players with absolutey no width. That was one of the reasons we've been very bad, with Erskine acting as some sort of winger but always coming inside offering no protection for the full back or actual width.

The formation against Aberdeen was spot on, especially first half with Spittal being able to hold his position.

Souttar/Butcher/Telfer is what I'd want to see. Rankin for Butcher when not fit or even Scott Smith if he's given more game time, as he looked very tidy on Saturday when he came on.

That midfield trio could work very well. Rankin done well on Saturday, but I think Butcher does what Rankin does best....better. They're both very iffy with their passing for starters. You've got Souttar - who as shown against the best midfield outwith Celtic - can do pretty much everything there, as well as Butcher offering physical presence and someone willing to go around the football pitch. A little less defensive awareness needing from Telfer, but he showed on Saturday he's willing to put the foot in.

ANier has shown nothing so far. Four massive games left, he can wait until pre season to show us if he's got it and not in important games.