Having slept on it, I'm in general agreement with Finn's sentiments. There are no guarantees, particularly for a team in our position. We asked for major changes and we got major changes. It might work. If these players down tools again, not only will they damage their own reputations and chances of interest from a decent team, but they'll potentially consign themselves to playing in the fizzy pop league next season.

If Goodwin's strength is putting out fires, that might keep us up. If he keeps us up, there's a good chance he'll be here for next season - when the remit will not be to put out fires but to build a squad capable of getting a top 6 finish and have a right good go in the cups. Is he the guy for that job?

If we go down, is there more chance of the take-over happening along with a clear-out of the Revolution grifters? Would there be more chance of getting Levein in as DoF with authority and a remit to put a long-term plan in place?

If we stay up, is it more likely we would remain under the control of Asghar's cronies?

Mixed feelings about all of this.

The club know that under no circumstances would the supporters tolerate another 'extensive global recruitment process' line only for the person already at the club to be appointed.

I agree with most that Goodwin was not the obvious candidate but at this time any appointment has risks, now he has been appointed I am hoping he can give us a better structure so we don't have to fear every attack from the opposition will lead to a goal.  I think it will be interesting to see how he sets up the defence and midfield, but fear a lack of options in goal will not help him.

If he does stay longer term I wonder what will happen with the remainder of the coaching team, given none of them were his selections.

Lets all hope he succeeds!

Tell you what gives me confidence in the man is he interviews well.
Unlike Fox who was rabbit in the headlights  from the get go.
Goodwin seems straight talker and addresses problems and sets out his answers clearly and directly.

(+ Did he play for Haccies in one of their get out of jail seasons ? )

Last edited by Shakey Isles Arab (03/3/2023 10:24 pm)

Loved seeing Goodwin screaming at the officials and players.

Assuming Goodwin doesn’t get the gig-

Robbie Neilson.
Neil Lennon.
Callum Davidson.
Owen Coyle.
Graham Alexander.
Mark Fotheringham.
Kevin Thomson.

The usual names out of contract currently…

Shedtastic wrote:

What a depressing list.

Totally agree. I have no clue who we look to if not Goodwin.

Whoever it is though the decision needs to be made ASAP so we can start preparations for next season.
 

Coyle or Goodwin for me