Andy Robertson

Close call, but went for Brewster because he helped get us our first Scottish Cup. Robbo will end up being one of Scotland's greatest in modern times if he keeps up his commitment and development, and I am very proud United played a part in that.

Craig Brewster.

Brewster for that goal gets my vote.

arabugsy wrote:

Andrew wisnae here lang enough tae attain cult status.

Away.

Score Update -

Craig Brewster - 6
Andy Robertson - 3
 

arabugsy wrote:

Brew, Andrew wisnae here lang enough tae attain cult status.

 
We both voted for the Monk when he got put out against Redford, he only made 21 appearances for us and was here for only six months. Andy was here for a full season and made 44 appearances for United. Time shouldn't be a factor, but everyone has their own definition of Cult.

I'm still voting for Brewster though.

Full Time -

Craig Brewster - 7
Andy Robertson - 4

Cult Hero II Winner - Craig Brewster


Brewster was born in Stobswell, Dundee and grew up a Dundee United supporter. He signed for the club as a schoolboy, but was not offered professional terms by then manager Jim McLean. Unable to find a senior club, Brewster dropped into junior football with Dundee Stobswell for a while, before signing for Forfar Athletic in 1985. At this time, his regular playing position was in midfield. His form at Forfar prompted the attention of Raith Rovers, who signed him in 1991. At this time he converted to striker, and formed a prolific partnership with Gordon Dalziel that helped Raith to the First Division title in 1993.

In 1993, Brewster returned to Dundee United, signing for the Tannadice club for a fee of £250,000. After a slow start in which he struggled to adapt to Premier Division football, Brewster's first season at Tannadice culminated in his greatest moment as a player, scoring the winner for United in the 1994 Scottish Cup Final against Rangers. However, the club was relegated a year later. Brewster helped them towards promotion back to the top flight in 1995–96, scoring four goals in one match against Dumbarton, but when his contract expired at the end of the season he decided to further his career elsewhere. With the Bosman ruling having just come into force, Brewster was entitled to move abroad on a free transfer, and he decided to take advantage of an offer from Greek club Ionikos FC.

While other Scottish players who moved to Europe at this time mainly returned home soon afterwards, Brewster remained at Ionikos FC for five seasons. His time in Greece included another national cup final appearance, but Ionikos FC lost the 2000 Greek Cup to AEK Athens.

In July 2001, Brewster went on trial at Hibernian,[1][/url] securing a return to Scotland in time for the 2001–02 season.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-2][2][/url] In his first season back in Scotland, Brewster formed a productive partnership with a young Garry O'Connor but due to budget cuts by Hibs, Brewster joined Dunfermline Athletic in 2002.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-3][3] He enjoyed some of the most consistent form of his career playing alongside Stevie Crawford, who had a been a youngster at Raith during Brewster's time there. Despite some clamour from fans and the media for Brewster to be called up to the Scotland squad, this never materialised.

After spells as player-manager at Inverness and Dundee United, Brewster joined Aberdeen in December 2006, signing a contract until the end of the 2006–07 season.[4][/url] He linked up again with Jimmy Calderwood, who had been his manager at Dunfermline. Brewster made his debut for Aberdeen as a substitute in a goalless draw with Hibernian on 2 January 2007,[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-5][5][/url] and he scored his first goal for Aberdeen with a header in a Scottish Cup tie against the same opponents eight days later.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-6][6][/url] Brewster then suffered a dislocated shoulder in a draw against Inverness.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-7][7][/url] Doubts were cast over his playing future, but Brewster returned in early March and he signed a six-month extension to his Aberdeen contract in May 2007.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-8][8]

His contract with Aberdeen was cut short, however, when he returned to management with Inverness in August 2007.[9][/url] He only played in two league games for Inverness in his second spell with that club, scoring the winning goal in a SPL match against Hearts.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-10][10] After being sacked as Inverness manager in early 2009, Brewster signed a contract with Highland derby rivals Ross County until the end of the 2008–09 season.

In November 2004, Brewster accepted the job of player–manager with Inverness Caledonian Thistle.[12] He helped to establish the club in the Scottish Premier League after John Robertson had left to take the position at Hearts.Brewster was appointed player–manager of Dundee United in January 2006.

His return to United yielded little success, however, as despite going unbeaten in his first three games, the remainder of the 2005–06 season brought just one win (against Livingston). Brewster had to wait four league games into the 2006–07 season for his second league win, and oversaw only two league wins in his nine months at Tannadice.On 29 October 2006, after a 5–1 defeat to Falkirk, Brewster and assistant Malky Thomson left by "mutual agreement".[13][/url] After leaving Dundee United he was linked with several managerial vacancies, including those at former clubs Dunfermline, Raith and Ionikos,[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-14][14] but he returned to playing with Aberdeen instead.

Brewster returned to management with Inverness in August 2007, after previous manager Charlie Christie had resigned.[9] Inheriting a team that was bottom of the league with no points, the team went on a good run of form culminating in December 2007 with a remarkable 3–2 win over Celtic, despite having been 0–2 down and having a player sent off. Pressure began to mount on Brewster in early 2008, however, when the team went on a run of seven consecutive defeats. Brewster stuck to a tough but unpopular stance regarding player discipline and contracts. Results eventually improved with the team finishing ninth in the league. This improvement was not maintained during the 2008–09 season, however. Brewster was sacked on 19 January 2009 following a run of seven consecutive league defeats, that left the team bottom of the league.

Brewster was appointed assistant manager of Ross County, working with manager Derek Adams. Ross County reached the 2010 Scottish Cup Final under their management. Brewster left the club in December 2010, soon after Willie McStay had replaced Adams as manager.

After six months out of work, Brewster was appointed first team coach of Crawley Town by manager Steve Evans in June 2011.[17][/url] Brewster was appointed caretaker manager on 9 April 2012, after the departure of Evans, until the end of the season.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-18][18][/url] Brewster guided the club to promotion to Football League One with three wins from their last six games.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-19][19][/url] He was retained as a coach when Sean O'Driscoll was appointed manager in May 2012.[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Brewster#cite_note-20][20] Brewster was again placed in caretaker charge, along with Steve Coppell, after O'Driscoll left in July 2012.

In November 2013, Brewster joined Whitehawk as Assistant manager, working alongside Darren Freeman.

Special Brew
 

Edmond Dantes wrote:

The shitiest manager we ever had.

I disagree.I think he set solid foundations for Levein.

Anyway this is about players and he was a great signing for Utd.

Wee Jim's last (allegedly).
 

arabugsy wrote:

Sieb22 wrote:

arabugsy wrote:

Brew, Andrew wisnae here lang enough tae attain cult status.

 
We both voted for the Monk when he got put out against Redford, he only made 21 appearances for us and was here for only six months. Andy was here for a full season and made 44 appearances for United. Time shouldn't be a factor, but everyone has their own definition of Cult.

I'm still voting for Brewster though.

Agreed on longevity factor.

But, technically I missed the Monk vote, and cult definition is still pending.
 

St Obswell wrote:

Congratulations Brew, you won it fair and square and i wish you well on your new venture down in Brighton 

 
Brighton will be a braw place for special brew 

Sieb22 wrote:

Well done organising another great competition TEK.

Cheers Siebby.
 

Good work Tek