Tekel Towers - DUFC Fans Forum

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?



30/11/2014 3:35 pm  #1


Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

4 numbers fae 1 tae 8 please.

 

30/11/2014 4:53 pm  #2


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

1234.

 

30/11/2014 7:02 pm  #3


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Many thanks Rodge.

The 6th Game of the 1st Round saw a very close fought contest eventually won by former maverick centre forward DUNCAN FERGUSON.His 5 votes were enough to ensure his safe passage through to the 2nd Round as a top seed.Joining him in the 2nd Round (albeit unseeded) will be former Cup hero CRAIG BREWSTER who finished in 2nd place.Eliminated fae the tournament at the 1st hurdle are 2010 Cup winner David Goodwillie and former Roma slayer Stuart Beedie.The latter sadly up against stiff competition and as a consequence registering no votes.

Round 1/Game 7 -

Grzegorz Szamotulski - Utd Goalie 2007-2008

Born - Gdansk,Poland (13th May 1976)
Appearances - 21
Goals - 0
Honours - 0
International Caps - 13 (Poland)
International Goals - 0

V's

Billy McKinlay - Utd Midfielder 1986-1995

Born - Glasgow,Scotland (22nd April 1969)
Appearances - 284
Goals - 31
Honours - 0
International Caps - 29 (Scotland)
International Goals - 4

V's

Jason Scotland - Utd Forward - 2003-2005

Born - Morvant,Trinidad+Tobago (18th February 1979)
Appearances - 60
Goals - 10
Honours - 0
International Caps - 41 (Trinidad+Tobago)
International Goals - 8

V's

Derek Lilley - Utd Forward 2000-2003

Born - Paisley,Scotland (9th February 1974)
Appearances - 90
Goals - 17
Honours - 0
International Caps - 0
International Goals - N/A

VOTING CLOSES TOMORROW (Monday 1st December) AT 6PM
______________________________________________________________________________________
Players Through Round 1 -

1.Paul Dixon (S)
2.Freddy Van der Hoorn
3.Andy Robertson (S)
4.Derek Stark
5.Craig Conway (S)
6.Ryan Gauld
7.Ian Redford (S)
8.Lars Zetterlund
9.Miodrag Krivokapic (S)
10.Christian Dailly
11.Duncan Ferguson (S)
12.Craig Brewster
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Players Eliminated -

1.Jerren Nixon
2.Michael O'Neill
3.Barry Robson
4.Sergio
5.Prince Buaben
6.Jason De Vos
7.Alan Main
8.Gary Bollan
9.David Robertson
10.Gordon Wallace
11.David Goodwillie
12.Stuart Beedie

     Thread Starter
 

30/11/2014 7:25 pm  #4


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Best player: Badger by a mile.

But my vote for Cult Hero in this round goes to the Monk!

 

30/11/2014 7:59 pm  #5


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Badger, quality player up there with Luggy and Narey as my fave Arabs ever.

 

30/11/2014 8:27 pm  #6


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

hard ain...badger's no a cult hero..a hall of famer is a hero...

but the other three are..deek lilley i loved..100%enter..jake escosse was another good player but i'm gonna go for the monk...what a fucking 6 months..thought that cunt was on drugs that friendly v barca lol

 

30/11/2014 9:40 pm  #7


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Badger 


Yeah yeah Industrial Estate
 

30/11/2014 10:58 pm  #8


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Jason Scotland.


Too much commotion
 

30/11/2014 11:29 pm  #9


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Badger


Hear their shout, hear their roar
They've probably had a barrel of ale and much, much more
Hooray, hooray, hooray, yeah
Over the hill went the swords of a thousand men
 

30/11/2014 11:34 pm  #10


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

I'll vote for Billy McKinlay.

I would say he deserves to be in the 'Cult Hero' Cup and i'll tell you why.If i was to have a 'Utd legends' competition would you say a guy who never won anything witth the club deserved to be in it?i would say NO,as harsh as that sounds.

I was also in two minds as to whether Derek Stark should be in the competition given he's won 3 trophies with the club.But i reasoned that a lot of Arabs of a certain age would probably walk by him in the street.Would they do that to Luggy,Narey,Hamish or Heggy?No chance.So i figured he was more deserving of 'cult' status than bona fide legendary status.

Just IMO.

     Thread Starter
 

30/11/2014 11:48 pm  #11


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

El Badger & good luck over in Spain !


We don't give a damn what the others say
We'll cheer on United all the way
For we are the Terrors of Tannadice
 
 

01/12/2014 11:22 am  #12


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

The Monk. Massive impact in a short spell.

 

01/12/2014 1:07 pm  #13


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Agree with what your saying mate bit lads with winners medals shouldn't automatically get ahead of others either
lads like doug smith etc never won a medal...yet danny cadametiri and ian britton hae medals

 

01/12/2014 1:27 pm  #14


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

The Cult status can be very subjective that's for sure. As your getting at TEK it should go toward the more overlooked player winner or not. For the most part I don't really look at number of appearances/goals or number of trophies etc. For me its just about that particular player, their character, rapport with the fans, highlight moments of their career which could be as little as a wonder goal or hugely significant goal but they only played 10 matches in tangerine and black, players that were just that bit different from the norm.

So on the back of that - The Monk.

Last edited by Hamiltonarab (01/12/2014 1:28 pm)

 

01/12/2014 8:42 pm  #15


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

Full Time -

Billy McKinlay - 5
Grzegorz Szamoltulski - 4
Jason Scotland - 1
Derek Lilley - 0

     Thread Starter
 

01/12/2014 8:57 pm  #16


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

not getting at tek at all hammy mate, doing a great job is oor tek....mearly explaining my decision on my cult heros...deffo very subjective

 

01/12/2014 9:36 pm  #17


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

stobievulture wrote:

not getting at tek at all hammy mate, doing a great job is oor tek....mearly explaining my decision on my cult heros...deffo very subjective

You are right Stobes in that a Utd player who's not won anything with us can still be a club legend,most definitely.

But guys like Doug Smith tend to be the exception rather than the rule.

He would however definitely be in a 'Utd Legends Cup' alongside other non-medalists like Finn Dossing,Duncan Hutchison etc bud (which i may do at some point if folk think it's worth it).
 

     Thread Starter
 

01/12/2014 9:38 pm  #18


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

No point in a United legends cup sir.

Narey would walk it. By miles.

And rightly so


Yeah yeah Industrial Estate
 

01/12/2014 10:29 pm  #19


Re: Dundee Utd 'Cult Hero' Cup II - Round 1/Match 7

huntedbyafreak wrote:

No point in a United legends cup sir.

Narey would walk it. By miles.

And rightly so

Probably right mate.
 

     Thread Starter
 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum