Extremely harsh to say the least

They sent everything down their right for the whole match and he did fine i thought.

Disappointed with Scobbie. Was skinned every time but thankfully Edje (my MoM) was on hand to bale him out otherwise we might have been 2 or 3 down at half time. Suspect Dee's will see him as a weak link and go for him in next match. Offered very little going forwards apart from poor crossing. Robson and Dixon would have been slated for that level of performance. He maybe captain but will have to up his game quite a bit to stay in the side.. 

I thought Scobbie did alright.

The boy Deacon looked a real handful and he is tge player we need to closely mark in the next Derby.

Thought Durnan and Edge were very good at CH btw.

Toshney the only weak link for me.

Tek wrote:

I thought Scobbie did alright.

The boy Deacon looked a real handful and he is tge player we need to closely mark in the next Derby.

Thought Durnan and Edge were very good at CH btw.

Toshney the only weak link for me.

 
Have to disagree Tek - thought Toshney did ok - cant recall any hideous errors.

Scobie I thought did well defensively in difficult circumstances - was piss poor going forward though

annanarab wrote:

Thought Tosh was generally ok but his failure to close down Allan properly allowed Allan to find O'Hara & cost us the goal. Similarly, thought Fraser was awful but his clever pass opened up the Dundee defence when we scored. 

 
Fraser was at fault for the Dundee goal, leaving Allan unmarked. Toshney then late getting over but for both our centre halfs to be giving 3yarda to the centre forward in the penalty box was criminal.

Scobbie won't be up against many opponents as fast in the Championship, but he was exposed for pace.

Toshney was poor- he toiled against a slow Allan, showed poor distribution, and was marking the Dundee player who hit the post late on. Not very well right enough.