- Hamiltonarab
- Tekel Towers 1st Team
Offline 
- From: Hamilton
- Registered: 02/9/2014
- Posts: 839
Re: fed poty
Erskine works hard, maybe too hard of late and ends up trying to make up for others I feel and ends up goosed! Not sure I would have gave him POTY, but he has been one not to hide away this season.
A few nods for Fojut, but have to say no way for me would he have got it. Has presence but no positional awareness.
- Foo Kin Twat
- Tekel Towers LEGEND
Offline
- From: Aybirdeen
- Registered: 12/3/2015
- Posts: 1,376
Re: fed poty
stobievulture wrote:
jmac there?
yeah
decent reception? Burnt at the stake? Wallet stolen and cash back for the club?
FAF Stobie 
I got a What's App that JM talked very well, but that IMO is not the problem, as I think he talks very well every time I hear him. The problem is transferring that from mindset to playing.....
That is where him and his coaching staff have under achieved, as if they had achieved, it would probably be them that are taking the likes of Norwich City into the playoffs and NOT Alex Neil and his. That said, I would hope he will learn, and learn fast, as otherwise his managerial career has already peaked. We need to be fitter, we need to stop giving away so many set pieces to the opposition as we just cannot defend set pieces and we need to toughen up!
On POTY, our season was effectively only up until the final whistle blew at Hampden v the Sheep, as from then til now we've been 
and I could not care less who won if I'm honest. If I was a United player and won it, it would be tarnished. If I had a vote, Erskine would have just edged it, but for overall improvement rather than consistency, as just like our team, he only lasts 2/3rds of a game, just like our season! Cases could be made and destroyed for Fojut, CalMor and Nads too, just as with Telfer in YPOTY.
That said, I'm just about to renew my season ticket for next season! #P2BAA 
Last edited by Foo Kin Twat (04/5/2015 8:32 am)
- Beharder
- Tekel Towers LEGEND
Offline
- Registered: 09/1/2015
- Posts: 1,815
Re: fed poty
The way to decide POTY should be if every player was to be sold now ( my idea not STs) who would go for the most? that should be the criteria. Erskine has had some great moments but also many poor matches.
However I keep reading that our season was over on Black monday going on that criteria the winner should be Stuart Armstrong
- bowers
- Tekel Towers LEGEND
Offline
- Registered: 07/10/2014
- Posts: 7,015
Re: fed poty
jmac there?
yeah
decent reception? Burnt at the stake? Wallet stolen and cash back for the club?
not sure tbh mate proberly wouldo been fine
- •
Thread Starter- St Obswell
- Arab Stallion
Offline
- Registered: 29/7/2014
- Posts: 1,877
Re: fed poty
The way to decide POTY should be if every player was to be sold now ( my idea not STs) who would go for the most? that should be the criteria. Erskine has had some great moments but also many poor matches.
However I keep reading that our season was over on Black monday going on that criteria the winner should be Stuart Armstrong
Lol, i knew someone would post that and I'm sure Stu would have indeed received a good few votes of irony. 
Hear their shout, hear their roar
They've probably had a barrel of ale and much, much more
Hooray, hooray, hooray, yeah
Over the hill went the swords of a thousand men
- bowers
- Tekel Towers LEGEND
Offline
- Registered: 07/10/2014
- Posts: 7,015
Re: fed poty
The way to decide POTY should be if every player was to be sold now ( my idea not STs) who would go for the most? that should be the criteria. Erskine has had some great moments but also many poor matches.
However I keep reading that our season was over on Black monday going on that criteria the winner should be Stuart Armstrong
so that is why it was strange from the Fed?
WOW
- •
Thread Starter- 1/1/2015
- Tekel Towers 1st Team
Offline
- From: Tha Hulltown
- Registered: 10/2/2015
- Posts: 98
Re: fed poty
This was a great night. JMac got a good reception, was too pissed to know what he said but he gave a speech an everyone was loving it.
- Waffelz
- Tekel Towers 1st Team
Offline
- Registered: 30/7/2014
- Posts: 393
Re: fed poty
What was Erskine's speech like?
- 1/1/2015
- Tekel Towers 1st Team
Offline
- From: Tha Hulltown
- Registered: 10/2/2015
- Posts: 98
Re: fed poty
What was Erskine's speech like?
Couln't hear him for all the "WTF's"
- arabugsy
- Boring bastard
Offline
- From: San Marie's
- Registered: 30/7/2014
- Posts: 2,273
Re: fed poty
For me, it should be based on votes cast after every game, then could be decided either on most moms, or most votes for season (my choice).
Then Squiddy would've won hands down. 
- Tek
- Administrator
Offline
- From: East Kilbride
- Registered: 05/7/2014
- Posts: 19,883
Re: fed poty
For me, it should be based on votes cast after every game,
Agreed.
Most votes per bus (say Shed57 for arguements sake) ...wins their Motm that day.The most Motm's per season wins each bus/groups own POTY.Then just a case of divvying up what player has won most FED bus/groups POTY.
One other thing i always wonder btw...why is POTY/YPOTY always announced with a few games still to go?
Say Ciftci (for example) scored a hat-trick in the upcoming Derby,you honestly gonna tell me he wouldn't be worthy of POTY after that?
Should always be held the night of the last game of the season IMO.Don't get why it's handed over before the seasons out.
I'm gonna hold Tekel Towers own POTY/YPOTY night after the Dundee game.(Trap 6 inspired idea)
- Waffelz
- Tekel Towers 1st Team
Offline
- Registered: 30/7/2014
- Posts: 393
Re: fed poty
They always do it the Sunday before May Day bank holiday.
- Tek
- Administrator
Offline
- From: East Kilbride
- Registered: 05/7/2014
- Posts: 19,883
Re: fed poty
They always do it the Sunday before May Day bank holiday.
I know but why exactly?
What's to stop it being held on the night of the last game of the season?